What else could work? Use it to generate alternatives before judging them.
What you will learn
Separate idea generation from evaluation.
Turn an unfamiliar idea into a small learning test.
What is it?
Creative thinking deliberately separates divergent option generation from critical judgment, helping teams escape binary “A or B” debates by exploring genuinely different mechanisms before selecting and testing the best fit.
Separate idea generation from evaluation. Six Thinking Hats is one way to deliberately switch between facts, possibilities, value, risk, feelings and process.
Core question
What else could work?
When to use it
Use it to generate alternatives before judging them.
Tools and techniques
Key techniques
Six Thinking Hats role switchingDeliberately separate green-hat possibility generation from black-hat risk critique.
Cross-mechanism option generationGenerate alternatives across distinct mechanisms—workflow, interface, automation, and policy—before ranking.
Low-cost concept probeTest two contrasting ideas in a small pilot to gather real effort, accuracy, and risk data.
Procedure: think it through step by step
Work through these steps in order, applying the tools above. Write down the answer to each step before moving on.
Take a recurring IT problem and produce five options from different mechanisms; delay ranking until all five exist.
Visual guide
WorkflowFrom situation through deliberate steps to outputRead the workflow as text
SituationAn operations team wants faster incident triage.
Step 1Frame the challenge
Step 2Generate divergently
Step 3Combine and test
OutputPilot two distinct approaches and compare effort, accuracy and risk.
Mind mapFour connected questions to keep in viewRead the mind map as text
Creative thinking
Challenge framing
Diverse ideas
Unexpected combinations
Small experiments
Detailed examples
Core scenario
Situation: An operations team wants faster incident triage.
How to apply: Generate runbook search, alert redesign, human-in-the-loop automation and training options before choosing a tool.
Outcome: Pilot two distinct approaches and compare effort, accuracy and risk.
02 / Reducing change-window downtime without expensive hardware
Situation: A team assumes the only way to cut maintenance downtime is to buy a duplicate active-active cluster.
How to apply: Generate alternatives across mechanisms: read-only degraded mode, queued async writes, schema-compatible rolling updates, and off-peak traffic shifting.
Outcome: Adopt compatible rolling schema migrations plus a brief read-only buffer, cutting user-visible downtime by 90% at minimal cost.
03 / Onboarding engineers to a complex legacy system
Situation: Writing a 200-page architecture manual is stalling because senior engineers lack time.
How to apply: Brainstorm non-manual mechanisms: recorded incident walkthroughs, seeded sandbox fault drills, pair-debugging rotations, and executable tests.
Outcome: Launch a sandbox fault-drill lab with 15-minute recorded walkthroughs that new hires complete in their first week.
Illustrative examples showing how the lens changes decisions; not measured outcomes.
Practice and keep learning
Watch out: Brainstorming many near-identical ideas is not diversity; novelty alone is not value.
Getting better at it
01 · Learn the foundationNotice when a discussion prematurely locks onto the first plausible idea or gets stuck criticizing every new suggestion.
02 · Build daily fluencyRun a strict 10-minute green-hat phase where every option must use a different mechanism before opening the black-hat risk review.
03 · Master under pressureTurn the top two contrasting concepts into cheap, reversible experiments so real evidence—not room politics—picks the winner.
Combine this lens with others rather than relying on it alone. Browse all thinkings
Review and make it your own
The idea to remember
Generate alternatives through different mechanisms before choosing which ideas deserve a test.
An outline for your notes
Use a problem of your own. Write a short answer to each prompt, then return after trying the method.
Challenge: write the desired outcome without the preferred tool.
Alternatives: list ideas based on genuinely different mechanisms.
Experiment: choose what to learn and the smallest useful test.
Check your understanding
Answer from memory before opening the suggested answer.
Are five versions of the same automation idea five alternatives?
Compare with a suggested answer
They may be variations rather than different mechanisms. Also consider eliminating demand, redesigning the process, improving information, or changing responsibilities.
Why postpone evaluation during generation?
Compare with a suggested answer
Premature rejection can narrow exploration to familiar options. Evaluation still follows, using evidence, value, feasibility, and risk.
Connect it to another idea
Creative thinking expands alternatives; design thinking grounds exploration in the needs and experiences of the people using the result.